*Food*
Pies
Large Pie
traditional new york style | 18”$21.95
Sicilian Pie
pizza sauce | mozzarella | thick sicilian crust$24.95
Grandma Pie
marinara | mozzarella | grandma style crust$24.95
Uncle Benny Pie
fresh mozzarella | cup & char pepperoni | pizza sauce | crumbled sausage | Mike's hot honey | basil | olive oil crust$32.95
Aunt Danielle Pie
vodka sauce | pepperoni | stracciatella cheese | fresh basil | Mike's hot honey$32.95
Bay Shore Pie
fresh mozzarella | pizza sauce | parmesan | olive oil crust$29.95
Crumbling Vodka Pie
fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | crumbled sausage | grandma style crust$30.95
The Honey Pep Pie
cup & char pepperoni | Mike's Hot Honey | basil | sicilian crust$31.95
Vodka Marghertia Pie
fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | parmesan |olive oil crust$29.95
Bar Pie
pizza sauce | light mozzarella | burrata | Mike's Hot Honey | basil | olive oil crust$31.95
Tri-Fecta Pie
fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | pizza sauce | pesto | olive oil crust$29.95
Meatball Burrata Pie
homemade meatballs | tomato sauce | burrata | basil | parmesan cheese | grandma style crust$31.95
Upside Down Pie
mozzarella | marinara | olive oil | sicilian crust$27.95
Buffalo Chicken Pie
marinated chicken | mozzarella | buffalo sauce$32.95
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie
breaded chicken | crispy bacon | mozzarella | cheddar | ranch$32.95
Thai Chili Chicken Pie
marinated chicken | mozzarella | thai chili sauce | grandma style crust$31.95
White Pie
ricotta | marscapone | mozzarella | white truffle oil | grandma style crust$29.95
Salad Pie
Choice of house salad or Caesar salad$34.95
Bruschetta Pie
balsamic-infused crust | fresh bruschetta | red onion | burrata cheese | basil | balsamic glaze$32.95
Vodka Sicilian Pie
vodka sauce | mozzarella | sicilian crustOUT OF STOCK$25.95
Eggplant Arugula Pie
$32.95
GF Personal Pie - Regular
Our GF crust is gluten and dairy free!$14.95
GF Personal Pie - Specialty
Our GF crust is gluten and dairy free!$13.00
Slices
Regular Slice
$3.67
Grandma Slice
$3.95
Sicilian Slice
$3.95
Uncle Benny Slice
$5.75
Aunt Danielle Slice
$5.75
Bay Shore Slice
$5.75
Crumbling Vodka Slice
$5.75
The Honey Pep Slice
$5.75
Vodka Margherita Slice
$5.75
Bar Slice
$5.75
Meatball Burrata Slice
$5.75
Tri-Fecta Slice
$5.75
Buffalo Chicken Slice
$5.75
Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice
$5.75
Upside Down Slice
$5.75
Thai Chili Chicken Slice
$5.75
White Slice
$5.75
Salad Slice
$5.75
Bruschetta Slice
$5.75Eggplant Arugula Slice
$5.75
Starters
Garlic Knots
$0.70+
Buffalo Knots
$0.85+
Pepperoni Pinwheel
$4.95
Broccoli Pinwheel
$4.95
Rice Ball (1pc)
$2.25+
Chicken Roll
breaded chicken | mozzarella | tomato sauce | parmesan & garlic seasoning$11.95
Garlic Bread w/Mozzarella
$7.50
Homemade Meatballs
tomato sauce | ricotta | parmesan | basil | rustic bread **Meatballs are NOT Gluten Free**$12.95
Mozzarella Sticks
$11.95
Fried Ravioli
$11.95
Wings
$15.95
Calamari
Traditional • Rhode Island • Arrabiata • Thai Chili • Buffalo$17.95
Arancini
arborio rice | chop meat | pecorino | vodka sauce$12.95
Whipped Ricotta Toast
Honey with Lemon Zest or Hot Honey & Chili Flakes$12.95
Tuscan Cuddles
prosciutto di parma | stracciatella cheese | arugula | fried dough$14.95
Burrata Rustica
burrata cheese | cherry tomatoes | olive oil | rustic bread |add Prosciutto di Parma +4$12.95
Calzone
topped with garlic & parmesan$12.95
Hand Cut Fries
Truffle Parmesan or Sea Salt$9.95
Vodka Fritters
spaghetti | vodka sauce | prosciutto | bread crumbs$12.95
Baked Clams
seasoned breadcrumbs | garlic | lemon | summer sauce$15.95
Summer Shrimp
white wine | lemon | butter | garlic sauce | rustic bread$14.95
Salads
House Salad
mixed field greens | cherry tomatoes | red onion | cucumbers | freshly made croutons | mozzarella$13.95
Caesar Salad
romaine | shaved parmesan cheese | parmesan crisps | freshly made croutons | homemade caesar dressing$14.95
The Salad
mixed field greens | honey crisp apple sticks | cherry tomatoes | freshly made croutons | candied pecans | parmesan crisps | cheddar cheese$15.95
Primiano Chop
soppressata | prosciutto | fresh mozzarella | onions | sliced cherry peppers | romaine | tomato | red wine vinaigrette$15.95
Side House Salad
$9.95
Side Caesar Salad
$9.95
Side The Salad
$10.95
Side Primiano Chop
$10.95
Heros, Sandwiches & Wraps
Chicken Parm Hero
tomato or vodka sauce | breaded chicken cutlet | mozzarella |semolina bread$14.95
Meatball Parm Hero
tomato or vodka sauce | homemade meatballs | mozzarella | semolina bread$14.95
Eggplant Parm Hero
tomato or vodka sauce | breaded eggplant | mozzarella | semolina bread$14.95
Shrimp Parm Hero
tomato or vodka sauce | breaded shrimp | mozzarella | semolina bread$14.95
Sausage Parm Hero
tomato or vodka sauce | grilled saussage | mozzarella | semolina bread$14.95
Sausage and Pepper Parm Hero
tomato or vodka sauce | grilled saussage and peppers | mozzarella | semolina bread$14.95
THE Hero
choice of protein | burrata cheese | tomato sauce | fresh basil | olive oil | parmesan | semolina bread$16.95
Primiano Chop Hero
soppressata | prosciutto | fresh mozzarella | onions | tomato | sliced cherry peppers | romaine | red wine vinaigrette | semolina bread$15.95
Focaccia Pesto Chicken Sandwich
grilled chicken | fresh mozzarella | roasted red peppers | house made pesto$14.95
Focaccia Pizzeria Chicken Sandwich
arugula | roasted peppers | breaded chicken | fresh mozzarella | balsamic glaze$14.95
Focaccia Chicken Caesar Sandwich
romaine | grilled chicken | parmesan | homemade caesar dressing$14.95
Focaccia Prosciutto Sandwich
prosciutto di parma | fresh mozzarella | tomato | basil | olive oil$14.95
Focaccia Caprese Sandwich
fresh mozzarella | tomato | basil | olive oil$13.95
Chicken Caesar Wrap
romaine | grilled chicken |parmesan | homemade caesar dressing | **This Item cannot be modified**$11.95
Pizzeria Chicken Wrap
arugula | roasted peppers |breaded chicken | fresh mozzarella | balsamic glaze | **This Item can not be modified**$11.95
Pastas
Penne Alla Vodka
housemade vodka sauce | penne pasta$21.95
Beggar’s Purse
cheese filled pasta pouches |crumbled spicy sausage | vodka sauce$21.95
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pasta
orecchiette | broccoli rabe | crumbled spicy sausage | garlic & oil$21.95
Baked Ziti
$21.95
The Mezzi Rig
mezzi rigatoni | mozzarella | spicy vodka sauce$21.95
Gnocchi
tomato sauce or creamy pesto$21.95
Endless Summer Shrimp Pasta
white wine | lemon | butter | garlic sauce | shrimp | spaghetti$24.95
Spaghetti & Clams
fresh littleneck clams | garlic | lemon zest | parsley | spaghetti | toasted bread crumbs$24.95
Pasta with Meatballs
$21.95
Pasta with Sauce
$16.95
Penne Broccoli and Garlic Oil
$21.95
Dinners
Parmigiana Dinner
tomato sauce | mozzarella | choice of side$25.95
Vodka Parm Dinner
vodka sauce | mozzarella | choice of side$25.95
Chicken Francese
white wine lemon butter sauce | choice of side$25.95
Chicken Stracciatella
breaded chicken cutlet | vodka sauce | creamy stracciatella cheese | choice of side$25.95
THE Pizzeria Chicken
breaded chicken cutlet topped with arugula | cherry tomatoes | red onion | fresh mozzarella | balsamic glaze | basil | choice of side$25.95
Endless Summer Chicken
breaded chicken cutlet | fresh mozzarella | white wine lemon sauce | choice of side$25.95
Trifecta Chicken Parm
fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | pizza sauce | pesto | choice of side$25.95
On The Lighter Side
Grilled Chicken Broccoli Rabe
sautéed broccoli rabe | garlic | seasoned grilled chicken$20.95
Grilled Pizzeria Chicken
seasoned grilled chicken topped with arugula | cherry tomatoes | red onion | fresh mozzarella | balsamic glaze | basil$20.95
THE Caesar Cutlet
breaded chicken cutlet | romaine lettuce | shaved parm | croutons | house-made caesar dressing |$21.95
Uncle Benny Pie
$32.95
fresh mozzarella | cup & char pepperoni | pizza sauce | crumbled sausage | Mike's hot honey | basil | olive oil crust
Customize your item
Optional
Optional
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
THE PIZZERIA Locations and Hours
The Pizzeria of Babylon
Open nowCloses at 10PM
The Pizzeria of Bay Shore
Open nowCloses at 10PM
The Pizzeria of Bayport
Open nowCloses at 10PM
The Pizzeria of Lake Grove
Open nowCloses at 9PM
The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst
Open nowCloses at 10PM
The Pizzeria of Smithtown
Open nowCloses at 10PM
The Pizzeria of Yaphank
Open nowCloses at 10PM
