Skip to Main content
PIZZA AT THE MALL, NOT MALL PIZZA
Authentic New York-style pizza, Italian favorites, and warm hospitality served fresh every day.

  • THE PIZZERIA

Menu

342 Smith Haven Mall, Lake Grove, NY
Food
Beverages

Food

Starters

  • Garlic Knots

    $0.80+

  • Buffalo Knots

    $0.85+

  • Chicken Roll

    Breaded chicken wrapped in fresh dough with red sauce, cheese and seasoning. Extra sauce for dunking comes on the side.
    $11.95

  • Buffalo Chicken Roll

    $11.95

  • Pepperoni Pinwheel

    $4.95

  • Buffalo Chicken Pinwheel

    $4.95

*Pies

  • Regular Pie

    Traditional New York Style Pie
    $21.95

  • Pepperoni Pie

    regular pie with cup & char pepperoni
    $25.95

  • Grandma Pie

    $24.95

  • Sicilian Pie

    $24.95

  • Margherita Pie

    fresh mozzarella | red sauce | parmesan cheese | olive oil crust
    $29.95

  • The Uncle Benny Pie

    fresh mozzarella | crumbled sausage | pepperoni | hot honey | basil | olive oil crust
    $32.95

  • The Aunt Danielle Pie

    vodka sauce | pepperoni | stracciatella cheese | fresh basil | hot honey | olive oil crust
    $32.95

  • Tri-Fecta Pie

    fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | red sauce | pesto | parmesan cheese | olive oil crust
    $29.95

  • Vodka Margherita Pie

    fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | parmesan cheese | olive oil crust
    $29.95

  • Crumbling Vodka Pie

    fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | crumbled spicy sausage | grandma crust
    $30.95

  • The Honey Pep Pie

    cup & char pepperoni | hot honey | basil | sicilian crust
    $31.95

  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie

    breaded chicken | crispy bacon | mozzarella | cheddar cheese | ranch dressing
    $32.95

  • Thai Chili Chicken Pie

    marinated thai chili chicken | mozzarella | thai chili sauce | grandma crust
    $31.95

  • Buffalo Chicken Pie

    marinated buffalo chicken | mozzarella | buffalo sauce
    $32.95

  • BBQ Chicken Pie

    marinated bbq Chicken | mozzarella | cheddar | bbq sauce
    $32.95

  • Upside Down Pie

    mozzarella cheese | topped with fresh made marinara | sicilian crust
    $27.95

  • White Pie

    ricotta | mascarpone | mozzarella | truffle oil | grandma crust
    $29.95

*Slices

  • Regular Slice

    Traditional New York Style Slice
    $3.97

  • Pepperoni Slice

    Traditional NY Style Slice Topped with Cup & Char Pepperoni
    $4.59

  • Grandma Slice

    $4.35

  • Sicilian Slice

    Traditional NY Style Sicilian Slice
    $4.35

  • Margherita Slice

    fresh mozzarella | red sauce | parmesan cheese | olive oil crust
    $5.75

  • Vodka Margherita Slice

    fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | parmesan cheese | olive oil crust
    $5.75

  • Uncle Benny Slice

    fresh mozzarella | crumbled sausage | pepperoni | hot honey | basil | olive oil crust
    $5.75

  • Aunt Danielle Slice

    vodka sauce |pepperoni |stracciatella cheese |fresh basil |hot honey | olive oil crust
    $5.75

  • Tri-Fecta Slice

    fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | red sauce | pesto | parmesan cheese | olive oil crust
    $5.75

  • The Honey Pep Slice

    cup & char pepperoni | hot honey | basil | sicilian crust
    $5.75

  • Thai Chili Chicken Slice

    marinated thai chili chicken | mozzarella | thai chili sauce | grandma crust
    $5.75

  • Buffalo Chicken Slice

    marinated buffalo chicken | mozzarella | buffalo sauce
    $5.75

  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice

    breaded chicken | crispy bacon | mozzarella | cheddar cheese | ranch dressing
    $5.75

  • Crumbling Vodka Slice

    fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | crumbled spicy sausage | grandma crust
    $5.75

  • BBQ Chicken Slice

    marinated bbq chicken | mozzarella | cheddar | bbq sauce
    $5.75

  • Upside Down Slice

    mozzarella cheese | topped with fresh made marinara | sicilian crust
    $5.75

  • White Slice

    ricotta | mascarpone | mozzarella | Truffle Oil | grandma crust
    $5.75

Beverages

Bottle

  • 20oz Coke

    $3.25

  • 20oz Sprite

    $3.25

  • 20oz Diet Coke

    $3.25

  • 20oz Dr. Pepper

    $3.25

  • Bottle Water

    $2.50

  • 20oz Cherry Coke

    $3.25

  • 20oz Ginger Ale

    $3.25

  • 20oz Gold Peak Lemon Tea

    $3.25

  • 20oz Root Beer

    $3.25

  • 20oz Coke Zero

    $3.25

  • 20oz Lemonade

    $3.25

Two Liter

  • 2Lt Coke

    $4.99

  • 2Lt Diet Coke

    $4.99

  • 2Lt Sprite

    $4.99

THE PIZZERIA Locations and Hours

The Pizzeria of Babylon

(631) 314-4500
217 East Main Street, Babylon, NY 11702
Open now • Closes at 10PM
View menu

The Pizzeria of Bay Shore

(631) 686-3555
11 Maple Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Open now • Closes at 10PM
View menu

The Pizzeria of Bayport

(631) 472-5959
606 Montauk hwy, Bayport, NY 11705
Open now • Closes at 10PM
View menu

The Pizzeria of Islip

(631) 581-9500
591 Main Street, Islip, NY 11751
Open now • Closes at 9PM
View menu

The Pizzeria of Lake Grove

(631) 652-9987
342 Smith Haven Mall, Lake Grove, NY 11755
Open now • Closes at 9PM
View menu

The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst

(631) 876-2777
177 S. Wellwood Ave., Lindenhurst, NY 11752
Open now • Closes at 10PM
View menu

The Pizzeria of Smithtown

(631) 771-1022
88 East Main Street, Smithtown, NY 11787
Open now • Closes at 10PM
View menu

The Pizzeria of Yaphank

(631) 448-7001
311 Boulevard E, Yaphank, NY 11980
Open now • Closes at 10PM
View menu
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement